TLDR
Iconic, reliable classic slices near Penn Station and MSG, highly praised by locals and legends alike.
Reddit Sentiment for NEW YORK PIZZA SUPREMA(based on 118 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
The user visited NY Pizza Suprema, a place they had saved for its vegan options. Despite a line out the door, the service was efficient. They tried the vegan Margherita slice, which cost $7, and found it to be delicious. Although they were hoping for vegan Alfredo or white pizza, they were satisfied with the Margherita. The restaurant has a spacious seating area in the back and the user indicated they would return.
Pizza Suprema, situated near Madison Square Garden, is presented as a long-standing and respected pizza establishment in Midtown. The reviewer samples a regular slice for $4.50, emphasizing its sweet sauce and overall quality. The pizzeria is lauded for being a reliable spot that has consistently delivered great pizza in the area for a considerable time.
Details
A cornerstone of the New York pizza scene, this institution near Penn Station is widely celebrated for its classic slices and nostalgic atmosphere [1][2]. Fans often cite it as a must-visit destination, bolstered by the late Anthony Bourdain's famous endorsement [3]. While the majority of patrons rave about the quality, some critics argue it is overrated or point to inconsistencies in slice freshness [4].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on classic New York-style pizza, with enthusiasts frequently recommending the 'Upside Down' slice, hot honey, and fig and bacon varieties [1][5]. While many enjoy the signature sweet sauce [6], some critics describe the pizza as overly moist, oily, or occasionally undercooked unless specifically requested otherwise [4][6].
Highlights / Recommended
"The 'Upside Down' slice, Hot Honey, and Fig & Bacon slices are frequently highlighted as standouts [5]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •upside down slice(3)
- •slice(2)
- •hot honey slice(2)
- •fig & bacon slice(2)
Caveats
Be aware that the restaurant can be very crowded due to its prime location [1]. Some patrons have noted inconsistent quality, such as undercooked crusts or messy slices, and there have been reports of the establishment being cash-only when card systems fail [4][6].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About NEW YORK PIZZA SUPREMA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Reccs For Someone Who Loves Sarges Lazarras Old
"One of the city's oldest slice shops, noted for being slightly more expensive now."
PositiveFrom post: How Often Do You Eat Big Name Pizza Papa Johns
"Mentioned as an example of a local shop the user would choose over chains if they were in the city."
PositiveFrom post: Lucky Charlies In Bushwick Perhaps The Best Pizza
"User recommends trying this place based on the original poster's preferences."
PositiveFrom post: Lucky Charlies In Bushwick Perhaps The Best Pizza
"User suggests this is the best move by Penn Station."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Pizza Tonight For Family Of 5 Would
"This commenter suggested NY Suprema near MSG as a good option for pizza if the original poster was looking for high-quality taste. They mentioned that while not fancy, their whole family enjoys it."
PositiveFrom post: Must Try Food You Can Only Pick One I Am Having
"Pizza Suprema is recommended as a place to get NY Pizza near MSG, accessible via NY Transit to Penn Station."
NeutralFrom post: Must Try Food You Can Only Pick One I Am Having
"Pizza Suprema is suggested as a place to get a classic NYC slice near Penn Station, accessible via NJ Transit from EWR."
PositiveFrom post: 7 Day Nyc Need Food Recommendations Updated With
"Pizza Suprema is recommended for pizza and is located on Eighth Avenue between 30th and 31st street."
PositiveFrom post: Recs For Last Restaurant To Visit Before I Move
"A local resident mentions going to NY Suprema Pizza at least three times a month and finding it very good."
PositiveFrom post: Recs For Last Restaurant To Visit Before I Move
"The user states that NY Suprema Pizza is their favorite for a white slice in NYC."
PositiveFrom post: Recs For Last Restaurant To Visit Before I Move
"This commenter agrees that NY Pizza Suprema is good."
PositiveFrom post: Recs For Last Restaurant To Visit Before I Move
"The commenter expresses a strong craving for NYC pizza when outside the city, highlighting NY Suprema Pizza as a recent obsession."
PositiveFrom post: Vegetarian Places To Eat Near Penn Station
"NY Pizza Suprema is recommended for its great slices and is noted as being vegetarian and vegan-friendly, with a mention of a past endorsement by Bourdain."
PositiveFrom post: Does This Style Of Pizza Slice Have A Name
"This user mentioned Suprema, stating that they offer a pizza slice with a "Veggie Medley" topping combination, though it does not include mini mozzarella balls."
PositiveFrom post: Need Help With Good Dinner Places
"This user recommended Pizzeria Supreme for pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Best Supreme Combo Pizza Slice In Nyc
"This user simply stated 'Pizza Suprema' in response to the OP's request for recommendations."
NeutralFrom post: Best Supreme Combo Pizza Slice In Nyc
"This commenter linked to the website of Pizza Suprema, suggesting it as a relevant option based on its name."
NeutralFrom post: Your Favorite On The Way Spot
"The commenter states that NY Pizza Suprema is a non-negotiable stop whenever they travel through Penn Station."
PositiveFrom post: Your Favorite On The Way Spot
"Every time the commenter visits NYC via Amtrak, they go directly to NY Pizza Suprema."
PositiveFrom post: Your Favorite On The Way Spot
"The commenter recalls NY Pizza Suprema as their first exposure to NYC pizza during college, being located near their dorms, and was initially disappointed with other pizzerias as they expected them to be as good."
Positive