Next.js logo

SAL & CARMINE PIZZA

Updated

Phone: (212) 663-7651

Address: 2671 BROADWAY 10025

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Quintessential NY slice joint w/ old-school vibe. A local fave for a no-fuss, classic pizza experience.

Reddit Sentiment for SAL & CARMINE PIZZA(based on 16 Reddit opinions)

81% Positive19% Neutral

Tags

italian 21italian-american 4american 2pizza 28slice 6View All

Neighborhoods

Upper West Side

Details

This classic New York pizza joint on the Upper West Side is a beloved spot for its no-frills, traditional slices. It's consistently praised for its old-school atmosphere and authentic taste. While many rave about its regular offerings, some find the sauce a bit too sweet.

Food Overview

This spot is renowned for its traditional New York-style pizza slices. While most customers find the pizza excellent and a quintessential experience, a minority opinion suggests the sauce is too sweet.

Highlights / Recommended

"The plain cheese slice is frequently recommended as a standout."

Mentioned Dishes:

  • •sauce(2)

Customer Sentiment

Customers overwhelmingly praise this establishment for its classic New York pizza slices and old-school atmosphere. A few, however, have noted the sauce can be a bit too sweet.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About SAL & CARMINE PIZZA

/r/FoodNYC/comments/1lc9hsz/visiting_nyc_and_bringing_wife_and_daughter_for/
This comment highlights the restaurant as the ultimate, no-frills, delicious, quintessential New York slice joint with an old-school atmosphere.
/r/FoodNYC/comments/1kcsade/mamas_too_on_a_nice_day/
A user suggests this spot for a NY slice if the line at Mama's Too! is too long, noting there's never a line here.
/r/FoodNYC/comments/1izky4g/the_most_underrated_and_overrated_pizza_in_nyc/
Multiple comments discuss this pizzeria as underrated and one of the best, with one user emphatically agreeing it's 'the TRUTH' for old-school thin slices.
/r/FoodNYC/comments/1jjwxrm/nyc_best_pizza_slice/
This establishment is recommended for a plain cheese slice, with another comment simply agreeing with its quality.
/r/FoodNYC/comments/1m8j9ek/best_food_places_around_108th_street/
This user considers it their favorite slice place in the city, praising the overall recommendations.
/r/FoodNYC/comments/1krhsdb/best_postwork_7pm_pizza_slice_option_where_i_can/
This user recommends the restaurant as a local favorite and a good option for pizza slices.
/r/FoodNYC/comments/1szm48m/best_bagel_or_slice_near_saint_john_the_divine/
Mentioned as a local favorite for classic NY pizza, with another comment confirming it as a vote for a classic NYC slice.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Best Bagel Or Slice Near Saint John The Divine

"Sal and Carmines is confirmed as a vote for a classic NYC slice."

Positive
Apr 30, 2026View Comment →

From post: Best Bagel Or Slice Near Saint John The Divine

"Sal and Carmine's is mentioned as a favorite for pizza, offering a real nostalgia play."

Positive
Apr 30, 2026View Comment →

From post: Best Bagel Or Slice Near Saint John The Divine

"Sal & Carmines, located at 102/Broadway, is identified as a local favorite for classic NY pizza."

Positive
Apr 30, 2026View Comment →

From post: Best Bagel Or Slice Near Saint John The Divine

"This commenter listed Sal & Carmines as an option, located at 102nd & Bway."

Neutral
Apr 30, 2026View Comment →

From post: Best Food Places Around 108th Street

"This user considers Sal & Carmine's their favorite slice place in the city and praises the overall list of recommendations."

Positive
Jul 25, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Food Places Around 108th Street

"This user states that Sal & Carmine's is their favorite slice in the entire city."

Positive
Jul 25, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Food Places Around 108th Street

"This establishment is listed as a recommendation."

Positive
Jul 24, 2025View Comment →

From post: Uws Musttry Quick Bites

"Sal and Carmines was listed as a favorite spot for quick bites on the Upper West Side."

Neutral
Jul 20, 2025View Comment →

From post: Where Is The Best Pizza In Harlem

"Patsy's is highly recommended for its quality, and the commenter also suggested Sal and Carmine and Mama's Too as worthwhile alternatives located just south of Harlem."

Positive
Jun 30, 2025View Comment →

From post: Visiting Nyc And Bringing Wife And Daughter For

"Sal & Carmine's is highlighted as the ultimate, no-frills, delicious, quintessential New York slice joint with an old-school atmosphere."

Positive
Jun 15, 2025View Comment →

From post: My Pizza List 3 Days Next Week

"Sal and Carmine on the UWS is described as 'excellent' by the commenter."

Positive
Jun 6, 2025View Comment →

From post: Where To Get Rc Cola

"Sal & Carmines on the Upper West Side has RC Cola available."

Neutral
May 29, 2025View Comment →

From post: Help Me Plan An Nyc Food Trip

"Sal and Carmines is recommended as a fast New York-style pizza option."

Positive
May 22, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Postwork 7pm Pizza Slice Option Where I Can

"This user recommends Sal and Carmine's as a local favorite."

Positive
May 20, 2025View Comment →

From post: Best Postwork 7pm Pizza Slice Option Where I Can

"This user recommends Sal and Carmine's for those in the Upper West Side."

Positive
May 20, 2025View Comment →

From post: Tourist Traps Or Real Deal Sorting Through Nyc

"Sal & Carmine's on the Upper West Side is regarded as the classic, quintessential, no-fuss NY slice."

Positive
May 16, 2025View Comment →