TLDR
Century-old coal-oven legend in Coney Island, famous for traditional pies and historic atmosphere. Limited weekend-only hours for takeout.
Reddit Sentiment for TOTONNO'S PIZZERIA(based on 40 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
Totonno's Pizzeria Napolitana is highlighted as one of New York City's most legendary pizzerias, having been family-owned and operated since 1924. The business has been actively seeking a buyer or investor for the past few years, as the current family members are aging and there is no one to take over, causing a strain. The pizzeria boasts a rare coal oven, which is a significant selling point in New York. The family's desire is for a buyer who will maintain their traditional methods, focusing on full pies and avoiding unconventional menu items like pineapple pizza. The listed asking price includes the one-story wood-frame building, but it is noted that there are no air rights included in the sale. Current operating hours are Saturday and Sunday from 12 PM to 5:30 PM.
Details
A historic Coney Island institution since 1924, this legendary spot is renowned for its traditional coal-oven pizza [1]. While it has been family-owned for a century, the business is currently seeking a buyer due to the owners' aging, which has introduced uncertainty regarding its future [1], [2]. Visitors are drawn to its authentic, old-school charm, though current operations are limited to takeout only during weekend afternoons [1], [3], [4].
Food Overview
The restaurant is celebrated for its classic margherita pies and signature white pizza, characterized by a garlicky, sweet-tart sauce and a robust thin crust that stands up to toppings [1], [4], [6]. While many fans consider it some of the best pizza in New York [7], others have criticized recent experiences as overpriced and inconsistent [2], [5].
Caveats
The establishment is currently takeout-only and operates under limited hours on Saturday and Sunday afternoons, making it difficult to visit [1], [3], [4]. Potential diners should be aware of reported inconsistency and the fact that the business is actively seeking a buyer [2], [5].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About TOTONNO'S PIZZERIA
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Why Would Anyone Trust Dave Portnoy About Pizza
"The commenter labels the negative assessment of the restaurant as criminal, citing it as some of the best pizza in that genre."
NegativeFrom post: Why Would Anyone Trust Dave Portnoy About Pizza
"The commenter believes this is the best pizza they have ever eaten and found Portnoy's review of it to be unfairly mediocre."
NegativeFrom post: Food Itinerary Etiquette And Opinions
"The user noted that Totonno's was on their radar but Coney Island is far, and they would be in Brooklyn on a weekday, making it an inconvenient option."
NeutralFrom post: Food Itinerary Etiquette And Opinions
"Totonno's in Coney Island is highly recommended, with the same family making pizza there for 100 years. They are only open on weekends and do not offer dine-in anymore, but the pizza is considered worth it."
PositiveFrom post: Nyc Food Instagram Feeds That Arent Annoying Af
"The commenter shared a negative experience at a restaurant promoted by Rob Martinez, noting that the establishment was overwhelmed by new customers, leading to long waits and strain on the staff. This raised concerns about the ecosystem of food creators and their impact on small businesses."
NegativeFrom post: Is Patsys Or Totonnos Still Good
"The owners of Totonno's are reportedly looking to retire, raising questions about its future."
NeutralFrom post: Is Patsys Or Totonnos Still Good
"It is suggested that Totonno's may not be worth traveling to Coney Island solely for the pizza."
NegativeFrom post: Is Patsys Or Totonnos Still Good
"Totonno's operates as takeout only and has limited weekend hours, which is important to consider if you are not local."
NeutralFrom post: Is Patsys Or Totonnos Still Good
"Totonno's can be inconsistent and is considered very pricey."
NegativeFrom post: Nyc Food Instagram Feeds That Arent Annoying Af
"Responding to criticism about Totonno's, Rob Martinez (the channel owner) explained the limited hours are due to the owner's age and family circumstances, and that the business is seeking a buyer. He also clarified his content monetization practices."
NeutralFrom post: Nyc Food Instagram Feeds That Arent Annoying Af
"This user critiqued Rob Martinez's video about Totonno's, finding the narrative disingenuous due to limited hours and service issues mentioned in other reviews. They also noted the restaurant was struggling and looking for a buyer."
NegativeFrom post: Totonnos Pizza Coney Island Likely To Close
"This commenter fondly remembers Totonno's Pizza as a special treat in the 90s and hopes they can stay open, suggesting it as a good option for tailgating before a Cyclones game."
PositiveFrom post: Totonnos Pizza Coney Island Likely To Close
"The commenter visited Totonno's Pizza in 2014 and found it to be great."
PositiveFrom post: Totonnos Pizza Coney Island Likely To Close
"This commenter notes the recent closure of Ciccio's and a pork store, expressing sadness about South Brooklyn losing its Italian establishments, including Totonno's."
NegativeFrom post: Totonnos Pizza Coney Island Likely To Close
"This visitor describes going to Totonno's Pizza in the summer, noting they were only open on weekends and that indoor dining was not allowed due to roof damage. Despite the circumstances and cost, they found the pizza fantastic, eaten by the ocean."
PositiveFrom post: Totonnos Pizza Coney Island Likely To Close
"This commenter finds Totonno's Pizza expensive for its size but considers it their favorite pizza in NYC and recommends trying it while possible, highlighting the garlic topping."
PositiveFrom post: Totonnos Pizza Coney Island Likely To Close
"This commenter laments the decline in quality and increase in prices at Totonno's Pizza after the pandemic and a fire, stating it used to be a contender for the best pizza in NYC."
NegativeFrom post: Totonnos Pizza Coney Island Likely To Close
"Following up on the previous comment, this user expresses confusion about family businesses that do not have long-term managers as a succession option besides family members or selling the business."
NeutralFrom post: Totonnos Pizza Coney Island Likely To Close
"In response to learning Totonno's Pizza invented white pizza, this commenter expresses excitement as white pizza is their favorite slice."
PositiveFrom post: Totonnos Pizza Coney Island Likely To Close
"This commenter reminisces about eating Totonno's pizza pies after going to the beach in the 90s, eating them hot off the car hood."
Positive