TLDR
Iconic, film-famous atmosphere with gilded decor and legendary history. A classic, albeit polarizing, choice for those seeking an opulent, old-world NYC vibe.
Reddit Sentiment for THE RUSSIAN TEA ROOM(based on 33 Reddit opinions)
Instagram Posts References
Just a block from Carnegie Hall, The Russian Tea Room is where Dustin Hoffman's character wined and dined in "Tootsie." This 1982 comedy earned ten Oscar nominations. The restaurant itself is described as being as over-the-top as the film, featuring gilded ceilings, red velvet booths, and samovars everywhere, making it a real NYC classic.
Details
A historic, ballet-inspired NYC landmark featuring opulent decor like gilded ceilings and red velvet booths [2]. While some patrons appreciate its unique, old-world atmosphere for late-night cocktails [3], [4], many diners report a decline in quality and poor value compared to other options [5]. Traditional dishes like beef stroganoff remain a notable highlight for some, despite mixed reviews on the overall experience [1], [6].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on classic Russian cuisine, with the beef stroganoff frequently identified as a recommended dish [1], [6]. However, consistent feedback highlights inconsistency, with some diners describing the food as mediocre or overpriced [5], [8]. While some guests enjoy the caviar or cocktails, others advise avoiding the restaurant in favor of more modern or high-quality alternatives [5], [7].
Highlights / Recommended
"The beef stroganoff is the most consistently recommended dish [1], [6]. Some diners also suggest visiting for a caviar tasting or cocktails [7]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •beef stroganoff(2)
Customer Sentiment
Customer experiences are deeply divided, ranging from praise for the venue's historic charm and exceptional service to significant criticism regarding its perceived decline in quality and high price point [5], [6]. Many diners suggest that unless visiting for specific sentimental or atmospheric reasons, the value proposition is often disappointing [5], [7].
Caveats
Many reviewers warn that the restaurant has passed its prime and suggest managing expectations for a potentially overpriced or underwhelming meal [5], [8].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About THE RUSSIAN TEA ROOM
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Where Would You Go Near Lincoln Center For A Late
"The Russian Tea Room is suggested as a truly special and unique idea."
PositiveFrom post: Where Would You Go Near Lincoln Center For A Late
"The Russian Tea Room is open until 11 PM and is presented as a unique and special option."
PositiveFrom post: Any 80s Looking Nyc Restaurants Kinda Like Bad
"The Russian Tea Room was recommended."
NeutralFrom post: Best Beef Stroganoff In Manhattan
"The original poster expressed their fondness for the beef stroganoff at The Russian Tea Room but is looking for a less 'stuffy' alternative."
PositiveFrom post: Replacement For Lillies Victorian Establishment
"The commenter states that Russian Tea Room has lost its quality over time and is not a good option."
NegativeFrom post: Replacement For Lillies Victorian Establishment
"The commenter advises against Russian Tea Room, stating its food is worse than Lillie's, which was described as 'mid'."
NegativeFrom post: Beef Wellingtons
"Following negative feedback, the original commenter clarified that while the Beef Wellington wasn't great, the ambiance was fun and it was freshly made."
NeutralFrom post: Beef Wellingtons
"In response to the Russian Tea Room recommendation, this user stated it 'shouldn’t be recommended to anyone except your worst enemies'."
NegativeFrom post: Beef Wellingtons
"This commenter initially recommended the Russian Tea Room for Beef Wellington."
NeutralFrom post: Dec 23 Near Rockefeller Center
"The user acknowledged that while the Russian Tea Room might be overpriced and underwhelming, it's considered a classic spot for its atmosphere."
NeutralFrom post: Dec 23 Near Rockefeller Center
"The Russian Tea Room was mentioned as a place for tea, though its value is debated."
NeutralFrom post: Dinner Recs Manhattan Midweek
"The Russian Tea Room is described as horrible."
NegativeFrom post: Dinner Recs Manhattan Midweek
"The Russian Tea Room is recommended for its 'old world' experience."
PositiveFrom post: Poor Quality Yet Expensive Restaurant
"This user suggested going to the Russian Tea Room for cocktails, finding the interior and vibe interesting, including the hallways."
NeutralFrom post: Poor Quality Yet Expensive Restaurant
"Responding to a question about its quality, this user stated that while not 'per se' bad, the Russian Tea Room was oddly expensive, and they barely touched the three dishes ordered."
NegativeFrom post: Poor Quality Yet Expensive Restaurant
"This user inquired if the Russian Tea Room is not good, as they had wanted to visit."
NeutralFrom post: Poor Quality Yet Expensive Restaurant
"This commenter suggested the Russian Tea Room, and in a reply, expressed that their recent experience was oddly expensive with mediocre food."
NegativeFrom post: Kindest Thing That Was Happened To You In A Nyc
"After initially being denied access to a decor piece designed by their father at the Russian Tea Room, the maitre d' became accommodating upon seeing photos, granting the users a private tour of the event room and offering ample vodka."
PositiveFrom post: Russian Restaurants And Dishes
"The commenter strongly advises against visiting The Russian Tea Room, expressing surprise that it is still in business."
NegativeFrom post: Best Way To Do Russian Tea Room
"This user supports Russian Samovar and notes that the Russian Tea Room would only be worth visiting for sentimental reasons, mentioning its upcoming centenary."
Neutral