TLDR
An authentic, kosher-certified staple for Jewish deli classics like matzo ball soup and corned beef, serving as a less-crowded, high-quality alternative to famous tourist hotspots.
Details
Renowned for its commitment to traditional Jewish-style deli fare, this spot is a staple in Manhattan for those seeking an authentic, kosher-certified experience [1]. Many patrons prefer this establishment over busier local competitors for its warm atmosphere, manageable wait times, and high-quality comfort food [36], [42]. While some debate its standing against other legendary delis, it remains a highly recommended destination for its classic menu [16], [17], [36].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on classic Jewish deli staples, earning high praise for its matzo ball soup [11], [33], [44], corned beef [46], [49], and brisket sandwiches [32]. Some diners note the pastrami is high-quality but distinct in style compared to other NYC institutions [7], [15], [25], and its strict kosher certification means certain combinations, like pastrami reubens, are not offered [7], [26], [31].
Highlights / Recommended
Mentioned Dishes:
- •pastrami(17)
- •matzoh ball soup(5)
- •matzo ball soup(4)
- •pastrami sandwich(3)
- •brisket(2)
- •soups(2)
- •chicken in the pot(2)
- •tongue(2)
- •pastrami reuben(2)
- •matzo ball kreplach soup(2)
Customer Sentiment
Patrons generally appreciate the warm, inviting atmosphere and find the food consistent and comforting [36], [41]. While many praise the quality of the classics, some recent feedback has expressed disappointment regarding fluctuating portion sizes and the quality of specific sides like pickles [22], [23], [53].
Caveats
Because the establishment adheres to strict kosher practices, dairy and meat are not served together, meaning popular items like cheeseburgers or pastrami reubens are unavailable [7], [10], [26]. Additionally, some diners have noted that portions can vary and the pickles may sometimes lack the expected crunch [22], [53].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About 2ND AVE DELI
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Katz Delicatessen Is Their Pastrami Good Shipped
"Generally very good, though quality can occasionally vary."
PositiveFrom post: Katz Delicatessen Is Their Pastrami Good Shipped
"Recommended as a reliable alternative for pastrami shipping."
PositiveFrom post: Any Musteat Restaurants In This General Vicinity
"Reiterates support for the recommendation."
PositiveFrom post: Any Musteat Restaurants In This General Vicinity
"Listed as a casual option."
NeutralFrom post: Any Musteat Restaurants In This General Vicinity
"Recommended for the area."
NeutralFrom post: Any Musteat Restaurants In This General Vicinity
"Mentioned as a restaurant in the area."
NeutralFrom post: Every Sunday Is Soup Sunday Im Running Out Of
"The commenter notes they still do a serious matzo ball soup."
PositiveFrom post: Distinguishing Places As Local Is No Longer Useful
"The user states they enjoy going to 2nd Ave Deli more than Katz's, appreciating the atmosphere and clientele of predominantly older Jewish individuals with distinct accents."
PositiveFrom post: Best Deli Pickles In Nyc Preferably Near Manhattan
"The pickles at 2nd Avenue Deli are criticized for being too small, limp, and lacking crunch."
NegativeFrom post: Best Deli Pickles In Nyc Preferably Near Manhattan
"2nd Avenue Deli is mentioned as a place to get pickles."
PositiveFrom post: Recommendations For Sandwich Restaurants That Are
"This commenter recommended 2nd Avenue Deli as a sandwich option."
PositiveFrom post: Where Do You Order In From In The City When Youre
"The commenter recommends matzo ball and kreplach soup, as well as pastrami from 2nd Ave Deli."
PositiveFrom post: Where Do You Order In From In The City When Youre
"The commenter recommends matzo ball and kreplach soup, as well as pastrami from 2nd Ave Deli."
PositiveFrom post: Where Do You Order In From In The City When Youre
"Second Avenue Deli is mentioned as a comforting food destination."
PositiveFrom post: Where Do You Order In From In The City When Youre
"Second Avenue Deli is mentioned as a comforting food destination."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can A Guy Get A Pastrami For Some Athome
"2nd Ave Deli is mentioned as one of the famous pastrami places that will sell pastrami by the pound."
NeutralFrom post: Which Place Gives You Insane Sized Meals Doesnt
"This user recommended 2nd Avenue Deli for its large pastrami sandwiches and good matzo ball soup and baked goods, preferring it over Katz's."
PositiveFrom post: Can Someone Explain The Difference Between A
"2nd Ave Deli is cited as an example of a Jewish deli in NYC that serves matzoh ball soup."
PositiveFrom post: Can Someone Explain The Difference Between A
"2nd Ave Deli is mentioned as a place that does not stand up to some New Jersey delis, according to the commenter's opinion."
NegativeFrom post: Can Someone Explain The Difference Between A
"2nd Avenue Deli is listed as a Jewish deli in NYC."
Positive