TLDR
Offers a highly-rated traditional high tea [1], with a vibe that aligns with a whimsical tea party [2]. A lovely place with good food [8].
Details
The Crosby Bar, part of the Firmdale Hotels, is a notable spot in Manhattan's SoHo neighborhood, celebrated for its vibrant atmosphere and well-regarded American cuisine. It's particularly recognized for its traditional high tea offerings, with multiple patrons highlighting it as a favorite in the city [1]. While many recommend the afternoon tea experience as a worthwhile alternative to more famous establishments [4], some diners have had less favorable experiences with both the food and service during afternoon tea [5].
Food Overview
The Crosby Bar is known for its American cuisine and is particularly lauded for its traditional high tea [1], which has been recommended as a strong alternative to other popular tea venues [4]. However, there are conflicting opinions, with one diner expressing dissatisfaction with both the food and service during their afternoon tea experience [5].
Caveats
Customer experiences with the afternoon tea service are divided, with some patrons expressing dissatisfaction with the food and service.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About THE CROSBY BAR
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Where Would You Go In The Les If It Was Your
"The Crosby St Hotel is mentioned as a lovely place with good food."
PositiveFrom post: Girls Trip
"Afternoon tea at the Firmdale hotels (including The Crosby) was suggested as a lower-cost version compared to Baccarat."
NeutralFrom post: Girls Trip
"The commenter found the Whitby hotel (same owner as Crosby) to be just okay."
NeutralFrom post: Girls Trip
"In contrast to another commenter, this user did not like the food or service at the Crosby Hotel's afternoon tea."
NegativeFrom post: Girls Trip
"The afternoon tea at Crosby Hotel was recommended as an alternative to The Plaza."
NeutralFrom post: Nyc Tea Party
"The Crosby Street Hotel is suggested as a potential venue for a tea party, aligning with a whimsical vibe."
PositiveFrom post: Nyc Tea Party
"The Crosby Hotel offers an afternoon tea, noted as a possible option for the event."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Tea Rooms
"This commenter identifies The Crosby Hotel as having one of their favorite traditional high teas in the city."
Positive