TLDR
Step into a beautifully restored 1920s apothecary for oversized, indulgent sundaes and iconic egg creams. A quintessentially nostalgic soda fountain experience perfect for dessert lovers.
Reddit Sentiment for BROOKLYN FARMACY & SODA FOUNTAIN(based on 25 Reddit opinions)
Will Hartman reviews Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain, a Carroll Gardens soda fountain famous for its over-the-top ice cream sundaes and egg creams, served in a unique, old-timey apothecary setting.
Details
Housed in a meticulously restored 1920s pharmacy, this nostalgic soda fountain serves as a neighborhood hub known for its old-school charm [1]. Visitors flock here for generously portioned ice cream sundaes and classic egg creams prepared with authentic silver mixing machines [1][2]. The menu leans into tradition, featuring housemade toppings and a variety of nostalgic floats that evoke a bygone era [3].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on American dessert staples, with standouts including 'embarrassingly large' sundaes, rich milkshakes, and traditional egg creams [1][2]. Customers frequently recommend the Black & White shake and the espresso-infused Affugazi, though some find specialty items like the S'mores cocoa less impressive on repeat visits [6][8][9].
Highlights / Recommended
"The 'Affugazi' sundae and the Black & White milkshake are frequently cited as top-tier choices for visitors [8][9]."
Customer Sentiment
Feedback for the establishment is overwhelmingly positive, with customers consistently praising the high-quality ice cream and classic soda fountain treats [4][5]. While most patrons consider their milkshakes to be among the best in the city, the menu is strictly focused on desserts, which some visitors note when seeking broader meal options [6][7].
Caveats
The establishment is focused solely on desserts, which may be a limitation for those seeking a full meal [7].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About BROOKLYN FARMACY & SODA FOUNTAIN
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Places To Take Kids That Are Young But Cultured
"Suggested as a place for ice cream and sodas."
NeutralFrom post: Anyone Know Where I Can Get An Affogato Like This
"Praised as the best ice cream and sundae place in the city."
PositiveFrom post: Anyone Know Where I Can Get An Affogato Like This
"Recommended their Affugazi, which is an espresso-soaked cake and ice cream sundae."
PositiveFrom post: Food Ideas For My 6 Yr Old Me Mostly In Manhattan
"Suggested as a place to visit if heading to Brooklyn."
NeutralFrom post: Where Are The Best Milkshakes In Nyc Right Now
"This user found Brooklyn Farmacy to be pretty good on a past trip, though they are looking for a specific type of thick chocolate/black & white shake similar to Dairy Queen but local and better."
PositiveFrom post: Where Are The Best Milkshakes In Nyc Right Now
"This user simply recommended Brooklyn soda farmacy."
PositiveFrom post: Where Are The Best Milkshakes In Nyc Right Now
"This user agreed that Brooklyn Farmacy deserves another mention for its offerings."
PositiveFrom post: Where Are The Best Milkshakes In Nyc Right Now
"This user praised Brooklyn Farmacy, specifically mentioning their frozen hot chocolate and noting that they also offer egg creams and unique float flavors, recommending it again despite it being mentioned in the original post."
PositiveFrom post: Whats The Nontouristy Cheesecake Factory Of Nyc
"Brooklyn Farmacy was suggested, but noted as being focused solely on desserts."
NeutralFrom post: Blend In Ice Cream Nyc
"The commenter suggested Brooklyn Farmacy as an option for building a sundae, implying a customizable dessert experience."
PositiveFrom post: Best Chocolate Milkshakes In Nyc
"Follows up on the original post, stating Brooklyn Farmacy's Black & White shake was very good and simple, becoming their favorite in NYC after a negative experience at Black Tap."
PositiveFrom post: Nearly Everything My Sister And I Ate In Our Week
"The S'mores cocoa from Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain was rated 7/10. It was a return visit, and while still good, it wasn't as memorable as the commenter remembered."
NeutralFrom post: Best Chocolate Milkshakes In Nyc
"Found Brooklyn Farmacy's milkshakes pretty good on a past trip but is looking for a specific type: chocolate soft serve base with chocolate syrup, like a better Dairy Queen."
NeutralFrom post: Best Chocolate Milkshakes In Nyc
"Enthusiastically declares Brooklyn Farmacy makes the best milkshakes."
PositiveFrom post: Best Chocolate Milkshakes In Nyc
"Recommends Brooklyn Farmacy."
PositiveFrom post: Best Chocolate Milkshakes In Nyc
"Agrees that Brooklyn Farmacy is a great choice."
PositiveFrom post: Best Chocolate Milkshakes In Nyc
"Tried Brooklyn Farmacy's Black & White milkshake on a previous trip and found it phenomenal."
PositiveFrom post: Best Chocolate Milkshakes In Nyc
"Seconding the recommendation for Brooklyn Farmacy."
PositiveFrom post: Best Chocolate Milkshakes In Nyc
"Also praises Brooklyn Farmacy's black and white milkshake."
PositiveFrom post: Best Chocolate Milkshakes In Nyc
"Expresses strong enthusiasm for Brooklyn Farmacy's milkshakes, specifically calling the classic chocolate one amazing."
Positive