TLDR
Perfectly moist cupcakes with decadent meringue buttercream and creative flavor profiles like creme brûlée. A reliable local staple for those seeking fresh, non-mass-produced sweets.
Details
Located on Bleecker Street, this bakery has built a reputation as a reliable go-to for indulgent treats, often cited as a top-tier alternative to other popular city shops [2]. While many patrons laud their moist cupcakes and decadent buttercream, the feedback highlights a range of experiences from beloved favorites to occasional misses [13], [14], [15]. The menu extends beyond standard bakes to include vegan options and even custom cake orders derived from their signature cupcake flavors [7], [10], [11].
Food Overview
The bakery is famous for its cupcakes, with specific praise for the creme brûlée and flourless chocolate cake options [3], [5]. While the buttercream is frequently highlighted for being perfectly moist and delicious, some visitors have encountered issues with synthetic-tasting cake batter or underwhelming flavor ratings [9], [13], [14]. Additionally, the shop offers Rice Krispie treats and accessible vegan options for those with dietary preferences [1], [10].
Highlights / Recommended
"The creme brûlée cupcakes and flourless chocolate cake are frequently recommended by repeat customers [3], [5]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •cupcakes(3)
Customer Sentiment
Overall sentiment is largely positive, with many customers hailing the bakery as a personal favorite for its freshness and decadent textures [6], [15], [16]. However, some diners have found certain flavor profiles to be unremarkable or artificial-tasting, showing a divide in expectations [9].
Caveats
A minority of reviewers have described the cupcakes as unremarkable or potentially synthetic in flavor, suggesting consistency may vary by specific order [9].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About MOLLY'S CUPCAKES
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: What Are Some Bakeriescakes That You Would
"The user finds them fresher and less 'mass-produced' than competitors."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Cupcakes In Ktown Or Soho For Today
"Mentioned as a recommendation for cupcakes."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Cupcakes In Ktown Or Soho For Today
"Highly recommended as a great place for cupcakes."
PositiveFrom post: Any Place To Find Buttercream Frosting Cupcakes
"This user recommends Molly's Cupcakes, noting that they have perfectly moist cupcakes and meringue buttercream, despite their exterior appearance."
PositiveFrom post: Any Place To Find Buttercream Frosting Cupcakes
"This user recalls Molly's Cupcakes making excellent buttercream, though not in flower shapes, and notes they were a bit greasy but decadent."
PositiveFrom post: Any Place To Find Buttercream Frosting Cupcakes
"This user recommends Molly's Cupcakes in the West Village, stating they are delicious."
PositiveFrom post: Any Place To Find Buttercream Frosting Cupcakes
"This user also recommends Molly's Cupcakes."
PositiveFrom post: Any Place To Find Buttercream Frosting Cupcakes
"This user recommends Molly's Cupcakes as a place that might have suitable cupcakes."
PositiveFrom post: Veganeggless Bakery Recommendation Not Preorder
"Molly's on Bleeker Street is noted for having vegan cupcakes available."
PositiveFrom post: Nearly Everything My Sister And I Ate In Our Week
"Molly's Cupcakes were rated as pretty unremarkable: crème brûlée (6/10), s'mores (4/10), and cake batter (4/10), with the cake batter flavor being particularly synthetic-tasting."
NegativeFrom post: Best Slice Of Cake Youve Ever Had In Nyc
"This user is interested in whether filled cupcakes can be ordered as cakes from Molly's Cupcakes."
NeutralFrom post: Best Slice Of Cake Youve Ever Had In Nyc
"This user notes that any cupcake from Molly's Cupcakes can be ordered as a cake."
PositiveFrom post: Best Slice Of Cake Youve Ever Had In Nyc
"Molly's Cupcakes have become a new favorite for this user."
PositiveFrom post: Who Has The Best Cake In The City
"Molly's is suggested as a cupcake replacement if Two Little Red Hens is unavailable."
PositiveFrom post: Who Has The Best Cake In The City
"The flourless chocolate cake at Molly's is the commenter's favorite."
PositiveFrom post: Who Has The Best Cake In The City
"The commenter forgot about Molly's Cupcakes but acknowledges they are good."
PositiveFrom post: Who Has The Best Cake In The City
"Molly's Cupcakes are a favorite, especially the creme brûlée ones."
PositiveFrom post: Best Rice Krispie Treat
"This commenter enjoys the Rice Krispie treat available at Molly's Cupcakes."
Positive