TLDR
Dark, plush steakhouse known for signature pepper-crusted cuts, exceptional sides, and legendary multi-layered chocolate cake.
Details
Renowned for its signature salt and pepper-crusted steaks [36] and a distinctive, dark, plush atmosphere [10], this establishment is a staple for meat lovers in Manhattan. While some diners debate its ranking against other iconic city steakhouses [6], [17], many regulars consider it the best in the city [32], [45], [52], frequently returning for the consistent quality [13], [44]. Its legendary multi-layered chocolate cake and indulgent sides, such as the duck fat potatoes, are frequently highlighted as must-try menu items [1], [34], [43].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on American steakhouse classics, headlined by their salt and pepper-crusted NY strip [18], [36]. Customers frequently rave about the indulgent sides, particularly the creamed spinach [19], [41] and duck fat potatoes [15], [43], while the multi-layered chocolate cake is widely regarded as a standout dessert [1], [40], [42]. While steaks are the primary draw, the restaurant also offers pescatarian-friendly options like sea bass and lobster tail [21].
Highlights / Recommended
"The salt and pepper-crusted NY strip is highly recommended, alongside the indulgent duck fat potatoes and famous multi-layered chocolate cake [1], [34], [36], [43]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •chocolate cake(7)
- •creamed spinach(4)
- •sides(3)
- •steak(3)
- •ny strip(2)
- •24-layer chocolate cake(2)
Customer Sentiment
Overall sentiment is highly positive, with many diners praising the consistent food quality and romantic, moody ambiance [10], [27], [49]. While a minority of guests occasionally debate the steak rankings or note concerns about changes after ownership transitions, most visitors describe it as a top-tier city experience [6], [32], [48].
Caveats
Some diners feel the steak quality is surpassed by other classic NYC competitors like Wolfgang's or Keens [6], [17], [31], and one user noted a decline in the size of the signature cake [40]. Additionally, those seeking prime rib will find it absent from the menu [42].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About STRIP HOUSE
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Where Did The Ny Strips Go Where Are They Best
"The commenter considers Strip House to be the best steakhouse in NYC."
PositiveFrom post: Where Did The Ny Strips Go Where Are They Best
"The commenter defends Strip House, stating it is still a great place and has never disappointed them."
PositiveFrom post: Where Did The Ny Strips Go Where Are They Best
"The commenter gives the restaurant a perfect score."
PositiveFrom post: Steakhousesteak Recommendations For Visitors Who
"Recommended for its meat and exemplary side dishes."
PositiveFrom post: Birthday Restaurant Steak Suggestions In Midtown
"Briefly recommended as a steakhouse."
NeutralFrom post: Strip House Is The Undisputed Best Steakhouse In
"This commenter believes the steak in the linked image looks perfect."
PositiveFrom post: Strip House Is The Undisputed Best Steakhouse In
"This commenter believes Strip House has declined in quality since being acquired."
NegativeFrom post: Strip House Is The Undisputed Best Steakhouse In
"This user views Strip House as a very good and underappreciated steakhouse."
PositiveFrom post: Strip House Is The Undisputed Best Steakhouse In
"While disagreeing with the term 'undisputed,' this commenter acknowledges their own positive experiences at Strip House and plans to return."
PositiveFrom post: Strip House Is The Undisputed Best Steakhouse In
"This user dislikes the pepper crust on the steak at Strip House."
NegativeFrom post: Strip House Is The Undisputed Best Steakhouse In
"Responding to a comment about the steak's doneness, this user states it was ordered medium rare and appeared to be cooked well, perhaps slightly on the rarer side."
NeutralFrom post: Strip House Is The Undisputed Best Steakhouse In
"The original poster has had multiple positive experiences at Strip House, praising their steaks and phenomenal service, and considers it the best steakhouse in the city."
PositiveFrom post: What Are Your Favorite Fancyhigher End Restaurant
"The 24 layer chocolate cake at Strip House is listed among favorite steakhouse desserts."
PositiveFrom post: Where To Lose Beef Virginity
"Strip House is recommended as a favorite steakhouse, also noting their amazing mashed potatoes."
PositiveFrom post: Delmonicos Or Gallaghers For Birthday Steak Dinner
"Striphouse (located on 12th St) is mentioned as the location of the commenter's best NYC steakhouse experience last year."
PositiveFrom post: Delmonicos Or Gallaghers For Birthday Steak Dinner
"Striphouse on 14th is a great spot, with the Steak Oscar being a notable dish. Mastros is also mentioned as good but loud."
PositiveFrom post: Delmonicos Or Gallaghers For Birthday Steak Dinner
"People like Strip House, although a commenter warned against it and Wolfgang's due to past health department closures."
NeutralFrom post: Harrys Fidi 28day Dryaged Porterhouse For Two
"In response to a comment praising Strip House, this user specifically mentions the '1000 layer duck fat potatoes' as a highlight."
PositiveFrom post: Harrys Fidi 28day Dryaged Porterhouse For Two
"This user considers Strip House to be the best steakhouse in NYC, highlighting its exceptional sides and high-quality meat."
PositiveFrom post: Last Minute Bday Dinner Carne Mare Or Strip House
"The author agrees that the creamed spinach is very good and loved Strip House in the past."
Positive