TLDR
Vibrant Mexico City-inspired party atmosphere featuring inventive, agave-forward cocktails and unique slushy drinks.
Reddit Sentiment for BOILERMAKER/ SUPERBUENO(based on 31 Reddit opinions)
Details
Recognized as the Best New U.S. Cocktail Bar at the Spirited Awards, this East Village hotspot delivers a high-energy, party-like atmosphere inspired by Mexico City [1]. The menu showcases inventive 'Mexican American' cocktails that utilize unique ingredients like pasilla chile, huitlacoche, and tajín [1], [3]. Guests can expect a vibrant setting filled with neon lighting and luchador masks, offering a memorable experience that balances adventurous drinks with solid food options [3], [6].
Food Overview
The cuisine centers on creative, Mexican-inspired cocktails and snacks, with reviews highlighting a divide between those who adore the innovative spirit of the drinks and those who find them overrated [3], [15], [16]. While dishes like the birria grilled cheese are highly recommended [19], some visitors advise that the experience is better suited for parties than quiet conversation [17], [19].
Caveats
The space is consistently described as very loud and crowded, which may not be suitable for those seeking intimate conversation [15], [16], [19].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About BOILERMAKER/ SUPERBUENO
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Looking For Recommendations For Cocktailfocused
"Described as one of the top cocktail bars in the city, located in the Lower East Side."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For Recommendations For Cocktailfocused
"This is a popular cocktail bar that is within walking distance of several other similar establishments."
PositiveFrom post: Wheres A Forlorn Gal Taking Herself Out To Dinner
"This commenter felt that the drinks at Superbueno were not very good."
NegativeFrom post: Choice Between Sip Guzzle Sip The Coop At Dcp And
"Superbueno is considered a potential option, but the user found it hit or miss depending on the drinks ordered, though the birria grilled cheese is highly recommended."
NeutralFrom post: Wheres A Forlorn Gal Taking Herself Out To Dinner
"The commenter suggested Superbueno for its festive vibe, which they thought would be good for distracting from sorrows."
PositiveFrom post: Choice Between Sip Guzzle Sip The Coop At Dcp And
"Superbueno is described as overrated, with its signature 'mole Negroni' not standing out. The user believes its high ranking might be due to a partnership with Cocktail Kingdom."
NegativeFrom post: Choice Between Sip Guzzle Sip The Coop At Dcp And
"Superbueno is described as loud, but the mixologists are friendly and open to conversation. The food is also considered good, and it's recommended to go early to secure a bar seat."
PositiveFrom post: Choice Between Sip Guzzle Sip The Coop At Dcp And
"Superbueno is noted for having better vibes than The Coop, though it can be loud. The food is considered solid."
PositiveFrom post: Choice Between Sip Guzzle Sip The Coop At Dcp And
"This user did not like Superbueno, contrasting it with their positive experience at Clemente Bar."
NegativeFrom post: Choice Between Sip Guzzle Sip The Coop At Dcp And
"Despite being loud and having 'party vibes', Superbueno's vodka soda is called the 'BEST cocktail ever had'. The establishment is noted for its lively atmosphere."
PositiveFrom post: Choice Between Sip Guzzle Sip The Coop At Dcp And
"Superbueno is recommended for groups and celebrations, with great takes on drinks and Mexican food, though it's described as more of a 'party vibe'."
NeutralFrom post: Choice Between Sip Guzzle Sip The Coop At Dcp And
"Superbueno is described as having a 'party vibe' that is loud and crowded, making it less suitable for the user's preference for interacting with mixologists. The cocktails are good but don't fit the desired vibe."
NegativeFrom post: Choice Between Sip Guzzle Sip The Coop At Dcp And
"Superbueno is considered good but not excellent, with a large bar and friendly bartenders, suitable for groups and celebrations."
NeutralFrom post: Day Drinking Itinerary West Villageles
"This user simply mentioned Superbueno."
NeutralFrom post: Lower East Side Dinner Before Attaboy
"Superbueno is on the user's saved list of places to check out."
NeutralFrom post: Lower East Side Dinner Before Attaboy
"The commenter expresses interest in trying Superbueno."
PositiveFrom post: Lower East Side Dinner Before Attaboy
"Superbueno is mentioned as a great option in the area."
PositiveFrom post: Where Are The Best Clarified Milk Cocktails
"This user simply recommended Superbueno."
PositiveFrom post: Birthday Weekend Food Lineup Would Love Feedback
"This commenter thinks Superbueno is great and offers good mocktails, noting it can be very loud, but warns that Attaboy is difficult to get into on a weekend."
PositiveFrom post: Birthday Weekend Food Lineup Would Love Feedback
"The original poster asked if Superbueno gets lively for post-dinner drinks."
Neutral