TLDR
An authentic, low-key Georgian gem in the West Village known for its standout khachapuri and charming garden seating.
Reddit Sentiment for OLD TBILISI GARDEN(based on 11 Reddit opinions)
Details
Tucked away in the West Village, this spot is celebrated as an incredible, low-key destination for authentic Georgian cuisine [2]. While many diners praise it as the best Georgian experience in the city [6], others have found the food quality to be inconsistent [10]. Be mindful of the payment policy, as the restaurant only accepts American Express and cash, which has led to friction for some patrons [3].
Food Overview
This restaurant specializes in Georgian cuisine, with many customers identifying it as the most authentic option in the city [6]. The khachapuri is highly recommended as a must-try dish [6], [8], though some diners have reported finding the overall food quality mediocre compared to other local options [10].
Caveats
The establishment has received a 'B' health inspection grade [4], and diners should note that they only accept cash and American Express cards [3].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About OLD TBILISI GARDEN
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Georgian Restaurant Date Night In Manhattan With
"Recommended specifically for its outdoor garden seating area."
NeutralFrom post: Where Would You Recommend Grabbing Dinner Solo
"This user found the Georgian food at Old Tbilisi Garden to be mediocre and recommended Askili Orchard as a better alternative nearby."
NegativeFrom post: Where Would You Recommend Grabbing Dinner Solo
"Old Tbilisi Garden was suggested as a dining option, especially recommended for the winter."
PositiveFrom post: Takeaway Georgian Restaurant
"Old Tbilisi Garden is recommended, with a link provided to their website."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Get This Type Of Bread Boat In Nyc
"This user believes Old Tbilisi Garden on Bleecker Street has the best khachapuri and is the best Georgian in the city, comparing Chama Mama as 'approachable' but less authentic."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Get This Type Of Bread Boat In Nyc
"This user believes Old Tbilisi Garden on Bleecker Street has the best khachapuri and is the best Georgian in the city, comparing Chama Mama as 'approachable' but less authentic."
PositiveFrom post: Where Can I Get This Type Of Bread Boat In Nyc
"This user recommends Old Tbilisi Garden in the West Village."
PositiveFrom post: Best Restaurants That Are Never Busy
"A note is made that Old Tbilisi Garden has a 'B' grade."
NeutralFrom post: Best Restaurants That Are Never Busy
"The commenter preferred Chama Mama due to rude service at Old Tbilisi Garden when they tried to pay with MasterCard, noting that Old Tbilisi Garden only accepts Amex and cash. While the food was good, the payment issue was off-putting."
NegativeFrom post: Best Restaurants That Are Never Busy
"Old Tbilisi Garden in the village is recommended as an incredible and low-key option for Georgian food, contrasting with the more popular but also good Chama Mama."
PositiveFrom post: Go To Repeat Restaurant
"This restaurant is listed as a recommended repeat spot."
Positive