Next.js logo

EMMY SQUARED PIZZA

Updated

Phone: (917) 463-3737

Address: 83 1 AVENUE 10003

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Detroit-style pizza w/ thick, cheesy crust. Not your typical slice, but a unique culinary experience.

Reddit Sentiment for EMMY SQUARED PIZZA(based on 2 Reddit opinions)

50% Positive50% Negative

Tags

italian 5american 4pizza 6detroit style pizza 3View All

Neighborhoods

East Village

Details

This popular pizza spot is known for its unique take on Detroit-style pizza, offering a thick, cheesy crust that's a departure from traditional New York slices. While some find it to be a standout, others have had less favorable experiences, citing issues with consistency and quality. Despite mixed reviews, it remains a talking point for pizza enthusiasts looking for something different.

Food Overview

The restaurant specializes in Detroit-style pizza, characterized by its thick, rectangular crust and generous toppings. While many enjoy the cheesy, flavorful pies, a notable number of reviews mention that the pizza can be undercooked or inconsistent in quality. One review specifically mentioned a negative experience with the pizza causing illness.

Highlights / Recommended

"The Detroit-style pizza is the signature dish, though customer experiences vary."

Customer Sentiment

Customer sentiment is divided, with some praising the unique Detroit-style pizza while others report negative experiences with food quality and consistency.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About EMMY SQUARED PIZZA

The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC
This thread discusses whether Emmy Squared's pizza is overrated, with some commenters agreeing and others defending it, noting it's a different style than typical NYC pizza.
The most underrated and overrated pizza in NYC
One user agrees that the restaurant is overrated and specifically mentions that they serve Detroit-style pizza.
Difference between Emmy Squared and Emily West?
A highly negative experience is detailed here, with one user reporting that the pizza was undercooked and caused them to vomit.
My pizza list. 3 days next week
One user mentions that Emmy Squared in the East Village has closed down.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Pizza Beer

"Garconavecunreve suggests getting a slice from EV Pizza in the East Village and then heading to a nearby bar."

Positive
Jul 1, 2025View Comment →

From post: My Pizza List 3 Days Next Week

"Emmy Squared is noted to have closed down and been replaced by a weed store, implying it's no longer an option for pizza."

Negative
Jun 6, 2025View Comment →