TLDR
Inventive, restaurant-quality ice cream flavors you won't find anywhere else. From mint chip to pistachio soft serve, a truly unique frozen dessert experience.
Instagram Posts References
OddFellows Ice Cream has launched a unique 'Breast Milk Ice Cream' flavor in collaboration with the brand Frida. The flavor is described as OddFellows' 'oddest creation to date' and is available as a limited-time pop-up. The ice cream itself is bright yellow and can be topped with gold flakes, served in a cone or cup. It is explicitly stated that the ice cream is not made from human breast milk. Customers can get a free scoop between 12 PM and 1 PM. The pop-up will run through August 10th.
Details
This ice cream shop is celebrated for its inventive and unique flavor combinations, often reminiscent of restaurant-quality desserts. Customers rave about the pistachio soft serve and fondly recall past unique offerings like creamsicle with tangerine cotton candy and amazing coffee and pumpkin flavors. Even their classic mint chip receives high praise.
Food Overview
The ice cream here is known for its creative and high-quality flavors, with mentions of excellent pistachio soft serve, mint chip, coffee, and pumpkin. A particularly unique 'Breast Milk Ice Cream' was noted for its surprisingly pleasant sweet and salty profile, though it was clarified not to be made from actual breast milk.
Caveats
One mention of a 'Breast Milk Ice Cream' flavor was clarified not to be made from actual human breast milk.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About ODDFELLOWS ICE CREAM CO.
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Where To Go For First Date In Brooklyn
"This ice cream shop is recommended as an option in DUMBO."
PositiveFrom post: Soft Serve In Nyc
"OddFellows is mentioned as another good option for pistachio soft serve. The author also fondly remembers a creamsicle soft serve with tangerine cotton candy from a past pop-up at Chef's Club in SoHo and finds their coffee and pumpkin flavors amazing."
Positive