TLDR
Polished Midtown Italian serving elevated regional dishes and homemade pasta in an upscale, moody setting. A top-tier destination for those who value refined atmosphere and exceptional culinary execution.
Instagram Posts References
Da Toscano is a highly acclaimed Italian restaurant that has relocated to a larger space in Midtown, Manhattan. The restaurant is known for its refined regional Italian cooking and polished service, offering an inviting atmosphere suitable for anniversaries, celebratory dinners, or elevated date nights. The article specifically praises several dishes, including roasted oysters with crab fat butter and chili vinegar, La Tur polenta tortellini with Parmigiano and honey, lamb agnolotti with drippings, pappardelle with Venetian duck ragù, and a 20-ounce bone-in ribeye with garlic butter. For dessert, Grandpa Lusk's cheesecake is mentioned as a simple, nostalgic ending. Reservations are released on Resy and tend to disappear quickly, particularly for prime time slots and weekends, indicating its popularity as a Midtown dining destination.
Details
Now situated in Midtown's Iroquois Hotel, this refined Italian destination has quickly re-established itself as a sought-after reservation [2]. Known for its polished service and inviting atmosphere, the menu features standout regional cooking including expertly crafted pasta and premium cuts [4]. Despite its popularity, it remains a favorite for those seeking an elevated yet classic dining experience [4].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on refined regional Italian cuisine, earning particular acclaim for its homemade pasta and sophisticated appetizers [1], [4]. Recommended dishes frequently mentioned include the lamb agnolotti, Venetian duck ragù pappardelle, octopus carpaccio, and braised artichokes [1], [4]. While some find the quality exceptional, a minority of diners feel certain items are overpriced compared to similar offerings in the city [4].
Highlights / Recommended
"Must-try items include the lamb agnolotti, pappardelle with Venetian duck ragù, and the octopus carpaccio [1], [4]. For dessert, the cheesecake and tiramisu sundae are widely recommended by returning guests [1], [4]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •octopus carpaccio(6)
- •pappardelle(6)
- •agnolotti(6)
- •fazzoletti(3)
- •duck breast(3)
- •roasted oysters(2)
- •tortellini(2)
Customer Sentiment
Diners consistently praise the restaurant for its superior food quality and welcoming vibe, often highlighting it as a preferred alternative to other high-profile Italian spots [1], [3]. While most feedback is overwhelmingly positive, some guests have noted concerns regarding pricing and occasional noise levels [1], [4].
Caveats
Potential diners should be aware that the restaurant has become significantly harder to book, often requiring reservations a month in advance [1], and some guests have noted that the pricing can feel high for the value provided [4].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About DA TOSCANO
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Birthday Dinner For Gf For 400 Budget Any Recs
"Mentioned as part of a list of restaurant recommendations."
NeutralFrom post: Suggestions For Brunch And Dinners For Weekend At
"The original poster has booked a table at da Toscano for Saturday evening before a show."
NeutralFrom post: If You Could Have Just One Dish From One
"The commenter recommended the duck pappardelle at Da Toscano."
PositiveFrom post: How Is Il Buco Alimentari Good For Out Of Town
"Da Toscana is recommended as a potential dining option."
PositiveFrom post: What Is The Single Best Restaurant Dish In Nyc In
"The octopus carpaccio from Da Toscano was mentioned as a recommended dish."
PositiveFrom post: Whats Your Favorite Singular Dish Or Entreeapp
"The commenter recommends the artichokes and agnoloti at Da Toscano."
PositiveFrom post: How Feasible Is It To Walkin To Da Toscano On A
"In response to a query about being overhyped, the commenter believes that similar or better quality pasta dishes can be found for less money, with comparable ambiance and service in both Manhattan and Brooklyn."
NegativeFrom post: How Feasible Is It To Walkin To Da Toscano On A
"The commenter states that Da Toscano has more availability after their move and considers it their favorite Italian restaurant in the city, worth a walk-in."
PositiveFrom post: How Feasible Is It To Walkin To Da Toscano On A
"The commenter was able to get a seat at the bar as a walk-in on the opening night."
PositiveFrom post: How Feasible Is It To Walkin To Da Toscano On A
"The commenter suggests that getting a walk-in at Da Toscano is easily doable, but also mentions they find it overpriced for what it offers."
NeutralFrom post: How Feasible Is It To Walkin To Da Toscano On A
"The commenter believes it's very realistic to get a walk-in at Da Toscano on a Tuesday, unless there's a specific event."
PositiveFrom post: Romantic Nyc Dinner Recommendations That Arent
"The original poster found Da Toscano and other mentioned restaurants to look great and thanked the commenter."
PositiveFrom post: Romantic Nyc Dinner Recommendations That Arent
"Da Toscano was listed among other restaurants that came to mind as fitting the criteria for a romantic dinner."
NeutralFrom post: Visiting From Seattle With A Group Critique My
"This user recommended Da Toscano as a potential Italian spot in Manhattan."
PositiveFrom post: Mystery Italian Place
"The commenter noted that Da Toscano, which used to be easy to reserve, now requires booking a month in advance."
NeutralFrom post: Mystery Italian Place
"Da Toscano is suggested as a dining option."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For An Italian Restaurant For A First Date
"Da Toscano was recommended as an Italian restaurant in Manhattan for a first date."
PositiveFrom post: Service Is The Priority My Moms 70th
"Da Toscano is mentioned as a non-Michelin option that could be suitable."
NeutralFrom post: Italian Dinner Recommendations
"This commenter recommended Da Toscano as a good Italian dining option."
PositiveFrom post: Alternative To Le Coucou After Proposal
"Da Toscano is listed as a restaurant recommendation."
Neutral