TLDR
Lively seafood spot w/ fresh oysters & amazing happy hour. Known for tasty linguini & buttery rolls.
Details
A seafood-focused establishment in Midtown Manhattan, Mermaid Oyster Bar is lauded for its solid seafood offerings, making it a good choice for pre-theater dining [2]. The restaurant is also known for its delicious linguini with clam sauce [5] and its happy hour specials, which include particularly well-regarded dinner rolls [16]. While not aiming for Michelin recognition, it provides a dependable dining experience for those seeking fresh seafood and oysters [1].
Food Overview
Mermaid Oyster Bar offers a strong seafood selection, with specific mentions of tasty linguini with clam sauce [5], chowder [7], and oysters [1]. Their happy hour is a highlight, noted for its value and the quality of its 'mind-blowing buttery dinner rolls' [16]. While generally well-received, some consider the lobster roll to be just 'not bad' rather than exceptional [18]. Coconut shrimp has also been noted positively [10].
Highlights / Recommended
"The linguini with clam sauce is highlighted as particularly tasty. Additionally, the happy hour is recommended, especially for the 'mind blowing buttery dinner rolls'."
Customer Sentiment
Customers generally have a positive view of Mermaid Oyster Bar, frequently recommending it for its seafood and happy hour deals. However, a few patrons find it just average, and one negative experience was attributed to a bartender [20].
Caveats
While generally recommended, one user reported a negative service experience attributed to a bad bartender [20]. There was also a query about the availability of al fresco dining [4].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About MERMAID OYSTER BAR
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Best Restaurant To Host A Corporate Dinner For
"Mermaid Inn Times Square is presented as an option starting at $60 per person plus $20 for beverages, totaling $80 per person. It has capacity for over 100 guests if private dining rooms are combined."
NeutralFrom post: What A Good Oyster Restaurant For Graduation
"Mermaid Oyster Bar is recommended."
PositiveFrom post: What A Good Oyster Restaurant For Graduation
"Mermaid Oyster Bar is suggested as a dining option."
PositiveFrom post: What A Good Oyster Restaurant For Graduation
"Mermaid Oyster Bar has several locations and is considered okay, though one user had a negative experience due to a bad bartender."
NeutralFrom post: Something Easy Lunch Or Dinner For 2 Demoralized
"Mermaid Oyster Bar is listed as a dining option."
NeutralFrom post: Seafood Restaurants Near 44th And 8th
"Lists Mermaid Oyster Bar in Times Square as a potential option."
NeutralFrom post: Seafood Restaurants Near 44th And 8th
"Provides a Google Maps link for Mermaid Oyster Bar."
NeutralFrom post: Semi Healthy Dinner Spots In Nyc
"Mermaid Oyster Bars were recommended for their amazing happy hour, with a humorous note about the 'mind blowing buttery dinner rolls'."
PositiveFrom post: Coconut Shrimp
"This user mentioned that the coconut shrimp handroll at Nami Nori is a favorite, and also recommended Grand Central Oyster Bar."
PositiveFrom post: Coconut Shrimp
"This user stated that Oyster Bar has excellent coconut shrimp."
PositiveFrom post: Broadway Theater Eats
"Mermaid Inn is mentioned as a dining option in the Midtown area."
NeutralFrom post: Seafood Or Sushi Theater District Blue Fin
"A commenter expressed their fondness for Mermaid Oyster Bar."
PositiveFrom post: Any Lobster Rolls Comparable With Maines
"The Mermaid Inn is mentioned as not bad for basic lobster rolls in the city, although their favorite is McLoon's in Maine."
NeutralFrom post: Judge My Restaurant Choices
"This commenter suggested adding Mermaid Oyster Bar to the list."
PositiveFrom post: Kips Bay Just Need A Little Oasis In This Desert
"The Oyster Bar in Grand Central is mentioned as an option, especially if the user likes oysters."
NeutralFrom post: Bryant Park Lunch Recommendations
"Mermaid Oyster Bar is suggested for chowder."
PositiveFrom post: Business Lunch Near 44th 6th
"The Mermaid Inn is suggested as a dining option."
PositiveFrom post: Best Linguini With Clam Sauce In Ny
"The Mermaid Inn in Manhattan is mentioned as having a tasty version of linguini with clam sauce, based on the commenter's last visit."
PositiveFrom post: Outdoor Patio Dining Greek Thai Or Chinese In The
"Mermaid Oyster Bar is mentioned, with a note to verify if they offer al fresco dining."
NeutralFrom post: Onenight Nyc Dinner Recs Classic Ny Vibes Bar
"Mermaid Oyster Bar in Midtown is recommended."
Positive