TLDR
Iconic "upside-down" square pizza w/ sauce on top & cheese under [1]. Signature Sicilian & Vodka pies are must-tries, alongside great baked clams & pasta [1].
Willa Moore reviews L&B Spumoni Gardens Dumbo, praising its incredible "upside-down" square pizza, a must-try when visiting the Dumbo area for its views.
Details
This Italian eatery is renowned for its distinctive "upside-down" square pizza, where the cheese is layered beneath the sauce, offering a unique textural experience with a crisp, oily crust [1]. While the Dumbo location may lack the original's ambiance, it delivers the same exceptional pizza quality, with praised options like the World Famous L&B Sicilian Pie and the highly recommended Vodka Pie [1]. Beyond pizza, the menu features well-regarded items such as Baked Clams with a perfect clam-to-breadcrumb ratio and a rich Bolognese pasta dish [1].
Food Overview
The restaurant is celebrated for its unique "upside-down" square pizza, featuring a crisp, oily crust with sauce layered over cheese [1]. Popular choices include the World Famous L&B Sicilian Pie and the Vodka Pie, both receiving high praise [1]. Other highlights include the Baked Clams, noted for their excellent clam-to-breadcrumb ratio, and a rich Bolognese pasta dish [1]. Some users also recommend the pistachio spumoni for dessert [3].
Caveats
The Dumbo location lacks the ambiance of the original L&B Spumoni Gardens [1]. Vodka squares must be purchased as a whole pie at the Dumbo location [2].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About L&B SPUMONI GARDENS
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Where To Get Dinner Near St Anns Warehouse In
"L&B is listed as a recommended dining option."
NeutralFrom post: Anyone Have Any Chicken Cutlet Sandwich Recs Have
"L+B is mentioned as a place that does a great chicken parm and other chicken cutlet sandwiches, though it's noted as being far."
PositiveFrom post: Pizza While Driving
"This commenter also recommends L&B and specifically suggests getting the square pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Pizza While Driving
"L&B Spumoni Gardens in Brooklyn is highly recommended as the original location for pizza, with the commenter mentioning frequent stops there during their childhood."
PositiveFrom post: Pizza While Driving
"The commenter enjoyed the spumoni, specifically the pistachio flavor, at L&B Spumoni Gardens."
PositiveFrom post: Pizza While Driving
"This is a recommended spot for NY style pizza in South Brooklyn, noted as being close enough to the bridge."
PositiveFrom post: Any Good Deep Dish In Nyc
"The user expresses strong positive interest in L&B Spumoni Gardens based on the description of its pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Any Good Deep Dish In Nyc
"L&B Spumoni Gardens is recommended for its unique pizza, known for having sauce on top of the cheese, and notes they recently opened a location in Dumbo."
PositiveFrom post: Lb Question
"A user highly recommends the Sicilian slice at L&B's Dumbo location and also suggests trying the spumoni, noting its cookie dough-like texture."
PositiveFrom post: Lb Question
"A user confirms that the L&B Dumbo location, like the original, requires purchasing vodka squares as a whole pie."
NeutralFrom post: Lb Question
"A user inquires if L&B's Dumbo location sells vodka squares by the slice, as they are eager to try it."
NeutralFrom post: Lb Question
"A user states that the pizza at L&B's Dumbo location tastes the same as the original, though the ambiance is different. They advise against ordering a regular slice and to stick with the square pizza."
PositiveFrom post: Lb Question
"A user confirms that the L&B Dumbo location sells slices/squares and highly recommends their square pizza, even though they haven't tried the original location."
Positive