Next.js logo

CARNEGIE DINER AND CAFE

Updated

Phone: (212) 664-1001

Address: 205 WEST 57 STREET 10019

View on Google Maps

TLDR

Huge, satisfying portions of American diner classics. Awesome desserts that are hard to make room for, all at reasonable prices.

Reddit Sentiment for CARNEGIE DINER AND CAFE(based on 7 Reddit opinions)

86% Positive14% Neutral

Neighborhoods

Midtown

Details

Experience a taste of classic American diner fare with a twist at this popular spot, known for its exceptionally large portions that will leave you satisfied. While the main courses are hearty, the desserts are visually stunning, though often overshadowed by the sheer volume of food. This eatery is a solid choice for a hearty meal at reasonable prices, offering a lively yet conversation-friendly atmosphere.

Food Overview

Offers classic American diner food with a standout chicken fried steak. Portions are notably large, making it difficult to save room for the visually appealing desserts. Overall, the food is considered good and reasonably priced.

Highlights / Recommended

"The chicken fried steak is highlighted as an exceptional and unique offering. While not explicitly reviewed, the desserts are noted as visually impressive."

Customer Sentiment

Customers generally have a positive view, praising the good food, generous portions, and reasonable prices, with some even humorously suggesting it's a great date spot.

Reddit Opinions & Reviews

Top Reddit Posts About CARNEGIE DINER AND CAFE

Recs near Carnegie Hall
Several users recommend Carnegie Diner for its good food, reasonable prices, and large portions. One user had a positive experience there and enjoyed their time.
Recs near Carnegie Hall
A commenter highlights the diner's huge servings and amazing-looking desserts, though notes the main courses are so large that trying dessert is challenging.
Child friendly restaurant near W 50th and 8th
Carnegie Diner is suggested as a child-friendly option near Carnegie Hall, with mentions of a theater menu.
Recommend me your go-to diner? Mine's jumped the shark.
The chicken fried steak at Three Decker Diner is mentioned as an exceptional dish that is rarely seen elsewhere.
Weill Café at Carnegie Hall for dinner
Carnegie Diner, located across the intersection, is noted as a decent and conveniently located option.

Recent Reddit Mentions

From post: Recs Near Carnegie Hall

"The original poster reported that they ended up going to Carnegie Diner and had a lovely time, expressing a desire to try other recommended places later."

Positive
Oct 23, 2025View Comment →

From post: Recs Near Carnegie Hall

"Carnegie Diner was positively reviewed for having good food and prices, with an atmosphere that was lively enough but still quiet enough for conversation. The commenter also humorously noted it was a good place for a date."

Positive
Oct 22, 2025View Comment →

From post: Recs Near Carnegie Hall

"A commenter affirmed that Carnegie Diner is '100%' good and reasonably priced."

Positive
Oct 22, 2025View Comment →

From post: Recs Near Carnegie Hall

"The food at Carnegie Diner is described as pretty good with huge servings. The desserts also looked amazing, but the commenter had never had the chance to try them due to the large main course portions."

Positive
Oct 22, 2025View Comment →

From post: Recommendations For Kidfriendly Dinner Options

"The original poster suggested Carnegie Diner as a potential dinner option for its theater menu and kid-friendly choices."

Neutral
Oct 8, 2025View Comment →

From post: Child Friendly Restaurant Near W 50th And 8th

"Carnegie Diner is mentioned as a suggestion."

Positive
Sep 26, 2025View Comment →

From post: Recommend Me Your Go To Diner Mines Jumped The

"The chicken fried steak at Three Decker Diner is highlighted as being exceptional, with a user noting they never see it elsewhere."

Positive
Sep 3, 2025View Comment →