TLDR
Authentic Greek bakery w/ handmade filo dough. Perfect for picnic items like spinach & cheese pies.
Caveats
The bakery is carry-out only. Some dishes, like the Galaktoboureko, may require heating before serving.
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About GOOD BAKLAVA LLC
This comment highlights the Galaktoboureko for its handmade filo dough, suggesting it's a must-try Greek dessert. It also notes that the dish may need to be heated.
This post praises the bakery for its homemade phyllo dough and mentions it as a good place to get picnic items, including spinach pie, cheese pie, and galactobouriko.
The restaurant is recommended as a worthwhile stop for Mediterranean options.
This bakery is mentioned as a carry-out only dessert option.
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Galaktoboureko
"The commenter likes Poseidon's Galaktoboureko because of its handmade filo dough, but notes that it needs to be heated."
PositiveMay 3, 2026View Comment →
From post: Best Greek Food Place Ie Not For A Date
"Poseidon Bakery in Hell's Kitchen is highlighted for its homemade phyllo dough and the ability to get picnic items like spinach pie, cheese pie, and galactobouriko."
PositiveApr 17, 2026View Comment →
From post: Food Recommendations
"Poseidon Bakery is mentioned as a worthwhile stop for Mediterranean options."
PositiveApr 16, 2026View Comment →
From post: Best Desserts In Hells Kitchentimes Square
"Poseidon Bakery is mentioned as a dessert option, with the clarification that it is carry-out only."
NeutralJan 14, 2026View Comment →