TLDR
A high-energy Vegas import in Greenwich Village, serving up dramatic tableside theatrics and classic steakhouse fare in a kitschy, glam setting.
Reddit Sentiment for GOLDEN STEER AT ONE FIFTH(based on 25 Reddit opinions)
The Vegas import Golden Steer brings its classic steakhouse experience, complete with kitsch decor and tableside flair, to Greenwich Village. Reviewer highlights include the tender filet au poivre and the dramatic cherries jubilee dessert.
Details
Bringing a slice of Las Vegas glamour to Greenwich Village, this transplant features Western-themed kitsch, mirrored ceilings, and a high-energy, theatrical dining experience [2]. The menu centers on classic steakhouse fare, with tableside service providing a dramatic flair that defines the meal [2]. While some diners enjoy the lively atmosphere and meat-centric options [1], [2], others have noted mixed experiences regarding consistency and value [1], [2].
Food Overview
The kitchen excels at tableside-prepared dishes like Caesar salad and flaming cherries jubilee [2]. While many diners praise the prime rib [2], dry-aged porterhouse [1], and filet au poivre [2], some have reported the steak to be bland [1] or found individual items like the baked potato to be overpriced [1].
Highlights / Recommended
"Highly recommended items include the 12-ounce filet au poivre, the tableside-prepared Caesar salad, and the flaming cherries jubilee [2]. Patrons also frequently praise the prime rib and dry-aged porterhouse [1], [2]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •prime rib(3)
- •caesar salad(2)
- •baked potato(2)
Caveats
The restaurant enforces a strict dress code and maintains age restrictions for young children [2]. Some diners have reported significant inconsistency in drink preparation and overall execution [1].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About GOLDEN STEER AT ONE FIFTH
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Where Can I Reliably Get Prime Rib Roast Beef In
"Mentions they opened a NYC location earlier this year."
NeutralFrom post: Where Can I Reliably Get Prime Rib Roast Beef In
"Notes they recently opened in NYC and offer two varieties of prime rib."
NeutralFrom post: Looking For A Good Prime Rib Spot In Manhattan
"The original poster expressed intent to check out Golden Steer based on the recommendation."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For A Good Prime Rib Spot In Manhattan
"This commenter recommended Golden Steer for its excellent prime rib."
PositiveFrom post: Swanky Dinner For Moms 70th
"Golden Steer was mentioned as a potential option, but the commenter noted having heard mixed things about it."
NeutralFrom post: Greenwich Village Steakhouse Strip House Or
"Following advice, the commenter chose Golden Steer and had a positive experience, enjoying the prime rib, baked potato, and French onion soup."
PositiveFrom post: Greenwich Village Steakhouse Strip House Or
"Based on the Vegas experience, the commenter finds Golden Steer's vibe fun but believes the food is average and may get lost in the competitive NYC market. They also note past restaurant failures in the NYC space."
NeutralFrom post: Greenwich Village Steakhouse Strip House Or
"Golden Steer is preferred over Strip House, especially if one is not primarily focused on alcohol selection and cocktails."
PositiveFrom post: Greenwich Village Steakhouse Strip House Or
"The commenter strongly recommends Golden Steer, stating it's clearly better than Strip House, which they find to be awful."
PositiveFrom post: Greenwich Village Steakhouse Strip House Or
"When comparing Golden Steer and Strip House, the commenter highlights Golden Steer's fun table-side services and suggests their meat game is top-notch, comparable to Strip House."
PositiveFrom post: Greenwich Village Steakhouse Strip House Or
"The commenter notes that Golden Steer is new and expects limited feedback. They also mention its average performance in Vegas and question if the NYC location will stand out, given past failures in that space."
NeutralFrom post: Greenwich Village Steakhouse Strip House Or
"The commenter prefers Golden Steer over Strip House, highlighting its speakeasy vibe, upscale feel, and impressive appetizers and steaks, specifically mentioning the lobster tail and prime rib."
PositiveFrom post: Steak Recs
"This commenter dismisses the NYT critic Ryan Sutton, calling him a pompous twit and questioning his reviews."
NeutralFrom post: Steak Recs
"Elaborating on the martini issue, the commenter explains that servers gave conflicting information about the gin used, and martinis were consistently served incorrectly."
NegativeFrom post: Steak Recs
"In response to a negative martini experience, the commenter asks if the other person was in the main dining room, suggesting potential consistency issues."
NeutralFrom post: Steak Recs
"The commenter experienced terrible martinis at Golden Steer (consistently wrong garnish, warm, and overly vermouthed), but found everything else very nice, including a great dry-aged porterhouse, steak mac and cheese, good service, and decor."
NeutralFrom post: Steak Recs
"This commenter had a mixed experience at Golden Steer, finding the atmosphere and service cool and vibey, and the Caesar salad and sides good, but the steak itself was bland."
NeutralFrom post: Steak Recs
"This commenter confirms a scathing NYT review of Golden Steer, mentioning it was mean-spirited but questioning if the restaurant is truly that bad."
NeutralFrom post: Steak Recs
"The commenter added Golden Steer to their list, appreciating the great bar room dinner atmosphere."
PositiveFrom post: Steak Recs
"In response to the negative review, the commenter states that if expectations are set for a swanky steakhouse with a large martini and tasty steak, Golden Steer meets those criteria."
Positive