TLDR
Authentic, old-school Italian red sauce joint in the Village. Renowned for its quiet, nostalgic atmosphere and classic comfort dishes.
Reddit Sentiment for GENE'S RESTURANT(based on 70 Reddit opinions)
Details
A timeless Village institution, this restaurant is celebrated for its classic red sauce Italian charm and consistent, old-school atmosphere [1], [16]. While many diners laud the experience as an unbeatable and authentic step back in time [37], [42], opinions on the kitchen remain polarized, with some critics labeling the food outdated or underwhelming compared to modern standards [45], [46]. Ultimately, it remains a beloved, dependable neighborhood staple for those seeking a quiet, no-frills environment [31], [33].
Food Overview
The menu focuses on classic Italian-American 'red sauce' staples, with highlights including the Spaghetti Bolognese [20], Shrimp Francese [27], [28], and Clams Casino [49]. While some praise these dishes as solid and comforting [36], [48], others express dissatisfaction, occasionally describing the offerings as unexceptional or lacking the quality of modern culinary alternatives [46], [47].
Caveats
The restaurant is frequently characterized by a very traditional, older demographic, leading some critics to describe the environment as dated [41], [45]. Additionally, some diners have noted that specific items advertised on the menu, such as prime rib, may occasionally be unavailable [47].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About GENE'S RESTURANT
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Bamontes Vs Johns Of 12th For Sunday Night Dinner
"Suggested for those looking for a more traditional Italian restaurant in the Village."
PositiveFrom post: Johns Or Genes Ive Been To Both But Im On The
"While both restaurants are considered subpar, the Clams Casino at Gene's is enjoyable."
PositiveFrom post: Johns Or Genes Ive Been To Both But Im On The
"A Father's Day lunch at Gene's was slow and quiet, with the restaurant not having prime rib despite menu indications. The food was only 'alright' and the experience lacked charm."
NeutralFrom post: Johns Or Genes Ive Been To Both But Im On The
"Gene's was not a good Italian restaurant even in the 1970s, with patrons seemingly content with basic dishes like 'spaghetti with ketchup'."
NegativeFrom post: Johns Or Genes Ive Been To Both But Im On The
"The food preparation at Gene's is considered outdated and was not good even in the 1970s."
NegativeFrom post: Johns Or Genes Ive Been To Both But Im On The
"Gene's is described as a 'Geriatric tomb' with microwavish food, unsuitable for a fine dining experience."
NegativeFrom post: Johns Or Genes Ive Been To Both But Im On The
"Gene's is a good restaurant that leans formal but isn't stuffy, suitable for enjoying cocktails. The food is rated as fine-to-good."
PositiveFrom post: Looking For A Good Prime Rib Spot In Manhattan
"This commenter recommended Gene's in Greenwich Village, an old-school spot that offers prime rib once a week. They highlighted the nice staff and old-school vibes."
PositiveFrom post: Is Genes Restaurant Any Good 73 West 11th St
"Gene's is described as dependable and old-school, perhaps not flashy, but known for a prime rib dinner that a friend adored."
PositiveFrom post: Is Genes Restaurant Any Good 73 West 11th St
"The commenter went to Gene's once and did not think it was good."
NegativeFrom post: Is Genes Restaurant Any Good 73 West 11th St
"This user shared a positive memory of having a 'fun guys night' at Gene's in the past."
PositiveFrom post: Is Genes Restaurant Any Good 73 West 11th St
"This commenter describes Gene's as an old-school, red sauce restaurant they've visited many times. They also recall John Leguizamo doing a promo for it, though they can't find it online."
PositiveFrom post: Is Genes Restaurant Any Good 73 West 11th St
"This restaurant is considered good, offering fine-to-good red sauce Italian food and old-school vibes that aren't a mere imitation. The commenter recounts a successful 'guys night' there involving drinks, chicken parm, and an early bedtime."
PositiveFrom post: Is Genes Restaurant Any Good 73 West 11th St
"Responding to a previous comment, this user believes that solid food combined with an awesome vibe nowadays is exceptional, as finding reliably good food is rare."
PositiveFrom post: Is Genes Restaurant Any Good 73 West 11th St
"This user suggests that one should simply try the restaurant to find out if it's good."
NeutralFrom post: Is Genes Restaurant Any Good 73 West 11th St
"This user suggests sticking with Jack's Wife Frieda instead of Gene's."
NegativeFrom post: Is Genes Restaurant Any Good 73 West 11th St
"This commenter, a third-generation New Yorker, strongly criticizes Gene's as the worst Italian-American restaurant in Manhattan, deeming it 'goddawful' and aimed at an older, less discerning clientele."
NegativeFrom post: Is Genes Restaurant Any Good 73 West 11th St
"While the food seems serviceable, this commenter is very impressed with Gene's website."
NeutralFrom post: Is Genes Restaurant Any Good 73 West 11th St
"This commenter found Gene's to be just okay. They used to frequent it about once a month but concluded that for the quality of food, they'd rather make their own pasta and salad."
NegativeFrom post: Is Genes Restaurant Any Good 73 West 11th St
"The food is decent, but the overall spot is great. The commenter enjoys sitting at the bar and highlights the bartender Franco for his attentiveness."
Positive