TLDR
An accommodating, reliable American brasserie perfect for large groups and business lunches. A go-to spot for consistent, crowd-pleasing comfort food in a lively, albeit loud, atmosphere.
Instagram Posts References
The Smith is a restaurant in NYC that is recommended for brunch, especially when a group is struggling to decide where to eat. It's characterized as a well-put-together version of a diner, providing solid food without causing stress. The reviewer highlights several dishes including chips and dip, the Smith Burger, a French dip sandwich, and a Caesar salad with a large parmesan crisp. The overall sentiment is that while the food isn't revolutionary, it's consistently good, and diners are advised to upgrade their fries.
This post highlights Sand Lunch, a restaurant located in the Flatiron district of New York City. The user enjoyed a comfort meal, specifically mentioning Potato Latkes with sour cream and apple sauce, a Tuna Melt, French Fries, and a Banana Split. The imagery showcases these classic diner-style dishes, suggesting a satisfying and nostalgic dining experience.
Details
Known as an accommodating, reliable American brasserie [7], this spot is a popular choice for large groups and business lunches due to its spacious layout and diverse menu [7], [8]. While some appreciate its consistency, it frequently faces criticism regarding its noise levels [15], [19] and controversial ownership [4], [16], [41]. Despite these mixed views, it remains a common recommendation for brunch, Thanksgiving, and quick, accessible bites [14], [29], [30].
Food Overview
The menu offers a wide range of standard American comfort food, often described as 'upscale diner' quality [52]. While dishes like the moules frites [47], bar steak [61], and Caesar salad [52] receive positive marks, other diners find the food unremarkable, sometimes criticizing items like burgers and steaks for poor quality [41], [62].
Caveats
The restaurant is widely criticized for its excessive noise levels [15], [19] and is subject to significant consumer boycotts due to its ownership by the Sackler family [4], [16], [41].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About THE SMITH
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Can Reservation For 9 7 Adults 2 Kids Avoid A Pre
"Suggested as a safe bet for large parties at reasonable prices."
PositiveFrom post: Can Reservation For 9 7 Adults 2 Kids Avoid A Pre
"Reliable for large group instances."
PositiveFrom post: Pick The Nyc Restaurant For This Specific Meal
"The commenter suggests the restaurant is primarily useful for using its restrooms when in the area."
NegativeFrom post: Pick The Nyc Restaurant For This Specific Meal
"The commenter strongly criticizes the restaurant due to the owners' connection to the opioid crisis and states the food is not good."
NegativeFrom post: Pick The Nyc Restaurant For This Specific Meal
"The commenter warns against this restaurant, characterizing it as an 'NYC Applebees'."
NegativeFrom post: Pick The Nyc Restaurant For This Specific Meal
"The commenter supports this choice as family-friendly, consistent, and having something for everyone."
PositiveFrom post: Pick The Nyc Restaurant For This Specific Meal
"The commenter critiques the restaurant as being slightly above the level of an Applebee's."
NegativeFrom post: Which Restaurants Do You Recommend If I Love
"The commenter sarcastically suggests The Smith."
NegativeFrom post: Birthday Restaurant Steak Suggestions In Midtown
"Criticized as the quintessential bad date restaurant with controversial ownership ties."
NegativeFrom post: Birthday Restaurant Steak Suggestions In Midtown
"Dismissed as a depressing choice for a birthday celebration."
NegativeFrom post: Place To Eat Lunch With Family Near The Lincoln
"The commenter agrees it is very loud and considers the food average."
NegativeFrom post: Place To Eat Lunch With Family Near The Lincoln
"The commenter states the food is fine and the location is convenient, but notes that nobody is truly excited to recommend it."
NeutralFrom post: Place To Eat Lunch With Family Near The Lincoln
"The commenter notes that the restaurant is extremely loud."
NegativeFrom post: Place To Eat Lunch With Family Near The Lincoln
"The commenter describes the place as mid and notes controversial ownership."
NegativeFrom post: If You Could Have Just One Dish From One
"The commenter recommended the tuna on crispy rice at The Smith, calling it a delicious appetizer."
PositiveFrom post: Where Are Your Favorite Cozy Quaint Nyc Pubs Bars
"The commenter reacts with amusement to the suggestion of The Smith."
NeutralFrom post: Where Are Your Favorite Cozy Quaint Nyc Pubs Bars
"The Smith is suggested."
NegativeFrom post: Whats The Nontouristy Cheesecake Factory Of Nyc
"This user called The Smith 'NY Appellees', comparing it to TGI Fridays."
NeutralFrom post: Whats The Nontouristy Cheesecake Factory Of Nyc
"This user pointed out that The Smith is owned by the Sackler family and advised against giving them money."
NegativeFrom post: Whats The Nontouristy Cheesecake Factory Of Nyc
"This commenter thanked another user for the information about The Smith being owned by the Sackler family."
Neutral