TLDR
Top-rated Hell's Kitchen gem serving up exceptionally simple, high-quality burgers and affordable combos featuring ice cream.
Details
Located in the heart of Hell's Kitchen, this spot has earned a loyal following for its consistently delicious, straightforward American fare [3], [12], [16]. Locals frequently praise the high quality of their burgers and the inclusive, value-driven combo meals that even feature ice cream [3], [13], [24]. It is widely considered a top-tier choice for a casual, no-fuss lunch in Manhattan [10], [18].
Food Overview
This kitchen specializes in classic American comfort food, with a reputation built largely on its "nice and simple" burgers and expertly prepared fries [12], [22], [27]. While burgers and fries are the primary draws, the menu also features well-regarded options like the veggie burger combo and bacon, egg, and cheese sandwiches [1], [28].
Highlights / Recommended
"The classic burger and fry combo is frequently recommended for its great value and taste [3], [12], [24]. Additionally, the veggie burger combo and the refreshing ice cream served with meals are highly regarded by diners [3], [28]."
Mentioned Dishes:
- •burger(4)
- •ice cream(2)
Customer Sentiment
Patrons consistently express strong support for this establishment, often citing it as a superior and more budget-friendly alternative to other local burger spots [7], [13], [16]. Many diners appreciate the inviting atmosphere and the owner's genuine connection to the community [12], [15], [24].
Caveats
While the burgers and fries are broadly praised, at least one visitor noted that the hot dogs may not be the standout item on the menu compared to other options [16].
Reddit Opinions & Reviews
Top Reddit Posts About Cubby's
Recent Reddit Mentions
From post: Hello New York Realistic Food Budget Suggestions
"Recommended for their veggie burger combo."
PositiveFrom post: Things We Ate In Nyc When We Remembered To Eat A
"Burgers were ordered from Cubby's on 10th Ave in Hell's Kitchen at the end of a long day. The burgers were described as nice and simple."
PositiveFrom post: Best Burger And Fries
"This user recommended Cubby's in Manhattan, mentioning it alongside Rolo's."
PositiveFrom post: Delirious Owner Returns With A Brand New Combo
"A special offer at Cubby's includes a potential for a free scoop of ice cream with the purchase of the new combo meal."
PositiveFrom post: Delirious Owner Returns With A Brand New Combo
"The owner of Cubby's is back with a new $11 burger and fries combo, available for a limited time in-store only. A portion of the proceeds will benefit local high school PTAs and sports teams."
PositiveFrom post: Great Eats For A Picky Teen
"Cubby's is recommended for burgers."
PositiveFrom post: Last Day Here And I Did Not Realize Jerk House
"Cubby's is recommended as a low-key, casual lunch spot near Central Park or Midtown."
PositiveFrom post: Best Saucey Burger In Nyc
"This user strongly recommends going to Cubbies in Hell's Kitchen."
PositiveFrom post: Xmas Cateringfood
"The commenter is suggesting Cubby's for catering, providing a link to their menu."
NeutralFrom post: Black Iron Burger Taste Was A Pleasant Surprise
"Responding to a previous comment, this user confirmed that Cubbies' fries are great."
PositiveFrom post: Black Iron Burger Taste Was A Pleasant Surprise
"This user stated that Cubbies "sucks" but acknowledged that their fries are great."
NeutralFrom post: Black Iron Burger Taste Was A Pleasant Surprise
"This user suggested Cubbies as a better option for burgers compared to 5 Napkin Burger."
PositiveFrom post: Disgruntled Owner Pleading With You To Order
"A user who is familiar with Cubby's praises their burgers, finding them better than another local favorite, and notes their location and price point within a competitive area."
PositiveFrom post: Disgruntled Owner Pleading With You To Order
"Cubby's is recommended as a great option for lunch in the Hell's Kitchen area."
PositiveFrom post: Disgruntled Owner Pleading With You To Order
"A user is mentioning that the restaurant in question is Cubby's in Hell's Kitchen and plans to place a direct delivery order soon."
NeutralFrom post: Disgruntled Owner Pleading With You To Order
"A user recalls having good ice cream at Cubby's and also found the burgers appealing."
PositiveFrom post: Disgruntled Owner Pleading With You To Order
"This user sent a direct message and stated that the OP's shop has excellent food."
PositiveFrom post: Disgruntled Owner Pleading With You To Order
"A user is asking for the restaurant's name to offer support, mentioning they would visit if in the area."
NeutralFrom post: My Favorite Spots In Hells Kitchen
"The original poster praised Cubby's for its very good burgers and loved their affordable combo meals, which include ice cream."
PositiveFrom post: Disgruntled Owner Pleading With You To Order
"This user visited Cubby's for a burger and fries, found it delicious, and wished the owner well. They also confirmed the restaurant's location in Hell's Kitchen."
Positive